How to Hire a Handyman to Fix a Leaky Faucet and Running Toilet
A leaky faucet dripping once per second wastes more than 3,000 gallons a year. A running toilet can waste 200 gallons every day. Beyond the environmental cost, you're watching money literally go down the drain every month. Most faucet and toilet repairs are straightforward jobs for an experienced handyman and can be completed in one visit.
This guide walks you through hiring a local handyman to fix both problems, from describing the issue and getting quotes to preparing your home and ensuring quality work. You'll learn what questions to ask, what these repairs typically cost, and how to avoid common pitfalls when booking home repair services.
- 01
Step 1: Document the problems and gather information
Homeowner taking a close-up photo of a leaking kitchen faucet for documentation Before you contact anyone, spend ten minutes identifying exactly what's wrong. For the faucet, note which handle leaks (hot, cold, or both), whether it drips when off or leaks around the base, and the faucet type (single-handle, double-handle, widespread). Take a photo if possible. For the toilet, lift the tank lid and watch what happens. Does water constantly run into the overflow tube? Does the flapper close properly? Is the fill valve hissing? Check the base for any water pooling on the floor. Write down the brand names stamped on the faucet and inside the toilet tank. This information helps handymen bring the right parts and quote accurately. Most importantly, turn off the water supply valves under the sink and behind the toilet if the leaks are severe.
- 02
Step 2: Request quotes from local handymen
Person using smartphone to browse and compare local handyman profiles and reviews Post your job with clear details: 'Need to fix a dripping kitchen faucet (Delta two-handle) and a running toilet (Kohler, water runs into overflow tube constantly).' Include the photos you took. Specify whether you want the pro to bring parts or if you'll supply them. Most handymen in mid-sized cities charge $75-$150 for the first hour and $50-$100 per additional hour. A faucet repair typically takes 30-60 minutes; a toilet repair 20-45 minutes, so expect quotes around $100-$200 for both jobs if they're straightforward. On Lumo, you describe the job, set your budget, and local handymen respond with their rates and availability. Compare at least three quotes, read reviews from previous customers, and check that pros carry liability insurance.
- 03
Step 3: Confirm parts, timing and access
Handyman organizing plumbing repair tools and replacement parts in a toolbox Once you pick a handyman, confirm the appointment time and discuss parts. Many pros prefer to assess the problem first, then pick up parts if needed, which may require a second visit or add 30-60 minutes. Alternatively, ask them to bring common faucet washers, O-rings, cartridges and toilet flappers and fill valves based on your photos and brand info. Clarify who pays for parts (usually the customer, typically $10-$40 for faucet parts, $8-$25 for toilet parts). Make sure someone over 18 will be home to let them in and that pets are secured. Point out where the main water shutoff is in case of emergency. In-app messaging on Lumo makes these details easy to confirm in writing before the appointment.
- 04
Step 4: Prepare the work areas
Empty cabinet space under a bathroom sink cleared and ready for plumbing repair work Clear the area under your bathroom and kitchen sinks. Remove cleaning supplies, trash cans and anything stored in the cabinet so the handyman can access shutoff valves and work comfortably. Lay down old towels under the sink and around the toilet base; even small leaks can drip during repairs. Make sure there's adequate lighting. If your under-sink area is dark, set up a work lamp or flashlight. Have a bucket or large bowl handy in case the handyman needs to catch water when disconnecting supply lines. These small steps make the job faster, which saves you money if you're paying hourly. A prepared workspace also reduces the chance of accidental damage to your belongings.
- 05
Step 5: Walk through the issues and watch the diagnosis
Professional handyman examining the inside of a toilet tank to diagnose a running water problem When the handyman arrives, show them both problems and explain what you've observed. A good pro will test the faucet, inspect seals and valves, then explain what's causing the leak (worn washer, damaged cartridge, loose connection). For the toilet, they'll watch a flush cycle, check the flapper and fill valve, and test the flush handle chain. Ask questions: 'What part failed?' 'How long will this repair last?' 'Is this a temporary fix or permanent?' If they recommend replacing the entire faucet or toilet instead of repairing, ask why and get a clear cost comparison. Honest handymen will explain that some old fixtures cost more to repair than replace. Stay nearby during the work but give them space to focus.
- 06
Step 6: Test the repairs and confirm the work
Homeowner testing a newly repaired kitchen faucet while handyman observes for leaks After repairs, test everything together. Turn the faucet on and off several times, checking for drips and leaks around the base and handles. Let it run for a minute while you inspect under the sink for any new drips from connections the handyman touched. Flush the toilet twice and watch the tank refill. Listen for hissing or running water. Wait five minutes and check again. If anything still leaks, point it out immediately so the pro can adjust or tighten connections. Ask for care tips: how often to replace the flapper, whether to avoid certain cleaners, how to spot early warning signs. Pay through the app once you're satisfied. On Lumo, payment is secure, you can add a tip (10%, 15% or 20% is standard for good work), and you'll be prompted to rate and review the handyman afterward.
- 07
Step 7: Monitor for the next 24 hours and follow up if needed
Person using flashlight to check under a kitchen sink for leaks after repair Check both fixtures a few times over the next day. Run the faucet morning and evening and inspect under the sink with a flashlight for any moisture. Flush the toilet several times and listen between uses. Occasionally a connection needs one more quarter-turn to stop a slow drip, or a new part needs to settle. If you notice any issues within 24-48 hours, message the handyman through the app. Reputable pros will come back to adjust their work at no charge if the problem persists. Take an after photo showing the dry, functioning fixtures for your records. This also helps if you need to show a landlord that repairs were completed or if you're documenting home maintenance for resale.
Pro tips
- Turn off water supply valves before the pro arrives if leaks are severe to prevent water damage and make the job safer.
- Ask for an itemized receipt that lists labor and parts separately; you'll need it for rental property records or homeowner's insurance claims.
- If the handyman says your fixtures are too old or corroded to repair reliably, get a second opinion or quote for replacement before deciding.
- Keep the old parts (faucet cartridge, toilet flapper) until you're sure the repair works, in case the handyman needs to reference them if issues arise.
Frequently asked questions
- Should I buy the parts myself or let the handyman bring them?
- Handymen usually prefer to supply parts because they know which brands fit properly and can exchange them if wrong. You'll pay a small markup (typically 10-20%), but you avoid buying the wrong part and making return trips to the hardware store. If you want to save money and are confident about the exact model, buy parts in advance and deduct that time from the quote.
- How do I know if I need a handyman or a licensed plumber?
- For straightforward faucet and toilet repairs (replacing washers, flappers, fill valves, cartridges), a handyman is perfect and costs less. Call a licensed plumber if you have pipe leaks, sewer line issues, need new fixture installation that requires cutting into walls, or if local codes require permits. Most handymen will tell you honestly if a job is beyond their scope.
- What if the problem comes back a week later?
- Contact the handyman immediately through the app and explain what's happening. Good pros warranty their labor for at least 30 days and will return to fix it free if they made a mistake or the part they installed was defective. If they're unresponsive, the platform's rating system and support team can help mediate.
Fixing a leaky faucet and running toilet is one of the most cost-effective home repairs you can make. The typical job takes under two hours and pays for itself in lower water bills within a few months. By documenting the problem, comparing local pros, and being present during the work, you ensure quality repairs at a fair price. A reliable handyman becomes a valuable contact for dozens of future home projects.
Photos are illustrative. Service prices are typical ranges and vary by city. How we write our guides.
More guides like this
How to Hire a Handyman to Mount Your TV and Hang Shelves
Mounting a TV and hanging shelves sounds simple until you're staring at studs, anchors, and a level. Here's how to hire a handyman who'll get it done right the first time.
How to Get Flat-Pack Furniture Assembled the Same Day
That flat-pack bookshelf or dresser doesn't have to sit in the box for weeks. Here's how to find a local handyman and get furniture assembled the same day, stress-free.
How to Book Handyman Repairs Before Selling or Renting Your Home
Small repairs can make or break a home sale or rental. Here's how to efficiently book handyman services to tackle those fixes before your listing goes live.